Why not combine a black and grey tank into one? Why separate?

Viewing 2 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #58740
      sean.malley
      Participant
        • Joined: Dec 2025
        • Posts: 2
        • Likes: 0

        Maybe a dumb question, but why are the black and grey tanks separate? Why not just have one??

      • #58756
        IA_Camper
        Participant
          • Joined: Jan 2024
          • Posts: 236
          • Likes: 255

          They actually have made RVs with one combined tank. Some older GMC motorhomes and bus conversions used them. It works, but owners have to watch water use closely because showers, dishes and toilet waste all compete for the same capacity.

        • #58759
          Tory Jon
          Keymaster
            • Joined: Nov 2019
            • Posts: 707
            • Likes: 1029

            Smell is likely part of it. A combined tank would put toilet waste directly below every drain in the RV, increasing the risk of sewage odors entering the living space.

            Separate tanks also make the system easier to manage. The black tank can stay closed until it has enough liquid for a proper dump, while the gray tank can be emptied more often and then used to rinse the sewer hose. A combined tank is possible, and some RVs have used one, but separate tanks are generally cleaner and more practical.

        Viewing 2 reply threads
        • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
        Don't have an account? Signup now
        Lost your password? Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.